User talk:Davogones
From Zelda Legends Wiki
(Difference between revisions)
Iron Knuckle (Talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Thank you for your advise (I'm still looking for the tildes in my keyboard). In my mother language (Spanish) I usually use those guidelines, but I'm not good enough at English. Here there's a suggestion I had given you before. | Thank you for your advise (I'm still looking for the tildes in my keyboard). In my mother language (Spanish) I usually use those guidelines, but I'm not good enough at English. Here there's a suggestion I had given you before. | ||
In the first days there have been problems with characters that have had different names through Zelda "history" (specially with those that didn't have a name in OoT and did in MM). Because of this, I think there should be adopted general lines about this. My proposal is: | In the first days there have been problems with characters that have had different names through Zelda "history" (specially with those that didn't have a name in OoT and did in MM). Because of this, I think there should be adopted general lines about this. My proposal is: | ||
| − | + | *For those characters that '''did''' have a different name in both OoT and MM (and also other names), they should be in different articles. (e. g. Malon (OoT) (MC?), Romani and Cremia (MM)). | |
| − | + | *For those that had an official name that doesn't look like a name (I think I'm not speaking very clearly) and that had a normal name in the following games, they should be together in an article called with the "normal name" (e. g. Anju, but with a redirect from Chicken Lady and Cucco Lady). | |
| − | -If they only have appeared in OoT and MM, the article should be called with both names. It doesn't matter whether they have an apparent name (e. g. Guru-Guru and Windmill music man) or not (e. g. Grog and Chicken Lady's brother) | + | : I agree with you up to this point. -[[User:Davogones|davogones]] 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST) |
| + | *If they only have appeared in OoT and MM, the article should be called with both names. It doesn't matter whether they have an apparent name (e. g. Guru-Guru and Windmill music man) or not (e. g. Grog and Chicken Lady's brother) | ||
| + | :I'm not sure I understand you here. Why does it matter if they only appeared in OoT and MM? If an official name is given for one but not the other, I think they should be grouped into one article. -[[User:Davogones|davogones]] 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST) | ||
P.D. Have you read my article about [[Rauru]]? When you read it, could you give me your opinion (and correct my ortographic mistakes. | P.D. Have you read my article about [[Rauru]]? When you read it, could you give me your opinion (and correct my ortographic mistakes. | ||
| + | :I skimmed it. I'll give it a detailed read later. -[[User:Davogones|davogones]] 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST) | ||
[[User:Arturo|Arturo]] 13:30, 17 January 2006 (EST) | [[User:Arturo|Arturo]] 13:30, 17 January 2006 (EST) | ||
Davo, did you get the TMC and FSA sheet, yet? I don't mind to insert all the entries myself, but that would take too much time if I did that manually.--[[User:Iron Knuckle|Iron Knuckle]] 14:00, 17 January 2006 (EST) | Davo, did you get the TMC and FSA sheet, yet? I don't mind to insert all the entries myself, but that would take too much time if I did that manually.--[[User:Iron Knuckle|Iron Knuckle]] 14:00, 17 January 2006 (EST) | ||
| + | :I did get it. I plan to write scripts to import the list into the lexicon, bestiary, and wiki. I'm going to email you some questions before I do that though. -[[User:Davogones|davogones]] 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST) | ||
Revision as of 20:42, 17 January 2006
Thank you for your advise (I'm still looking for the tildes in my keyboard). In my mother language (Spanish) I usually use those guidelines, but I'm not good enough at English. Here there's a suggestion I had given you before. In the first days there have been problems with characters that have had different names through Zelda "history" (specially with those that didn't have a name in OoT and did in MM). Because of this, I think there should be adopted general lines about this. My proposal is:
- For those characters that did have a different name in both OoT and MM (and also other names), they should be in different articles. (e. g. Malon (OoT) (MC?), Romani and Cremia (MM)).
- For those that had an official name that doesn't look like a name (I think I'm not speaking very clearly) and that had a normal name in the following games, they should be together in an article called with the "normal name" (e. g. Anju, but with a redirect from Chicken Lady and Cucco Lady).
- I agree with you up to this point. -davogones 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST)
- If they only have appeared in OoT and MM, the article should be called with both names. It doesn't matter whether they have an apparent name (e. g. Guru-Guru and Windmill music man) or not (e. g. Grog and Chicken Lady's brother)
- I'm not sure I understand you here. Why does it matter if they only appeared in OoT and MM? If an official name is given for one but not the other, I think they should be grouped into one article. -davogones 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST)
P.D. Have you read my article about Rauru? When you read it, could you give me your opinion (and correct my ortographic mistakes.
- I skimmed it. I'll give it a detailed read later. -davogones 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST)
Arturo 13:30, 17 January 2006 (EST)
Davo, did you get the TMC and FSA sheet, yet? I don't mind to insert all the entries myself, but that would take too much time if I did that manually.--Iron Knuckle 14:00, 17 January 2006 (EST)
- I did get it. I plan to write scripts to import the list into the lexicon, bestiary, and wiki. I'm going to email you some questions before I do that though. -davogones 15:42, 17 January 2006 (EST)
